The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) has published guidance on the related party transaction rules in the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013 (FMC Act) that apply to registered managed investment schemes.
The guidance responds to inconsistent market practice and difficulty in operationalising the rules. It does not change the law. It explains how the FMA considers the existing law should be applied.
What are the related party transaction rules under the FMC Act?
Under the FMC Act, a manager of a registered scheme, and any investment manager, administration manager or other person to whom the manager has contracted out some or all its functions, is prohibited from entering into a transaction that provides a related party benefit. The prohibition does not apply if the manager notifies the supervisor of the transaction and either:
obtains the supervisor's consent; or
the transaction or the related party benefits to be given are permitted under the Act and the manager certifies to that effect (for example, because the benefit is given on arm's-length terms).
A related party benefit is a benefit that is given out of scheme property or creates an exposure to loss for scheme property, and that is given to, or received by, a related party of the scheme. Fees or expenses paid to or reimbursed to the manager under the FMC Act or the scheme's governing document are excluded.
What is the FMA’s view?
A key message from the FMA is to take a risk-based approach to related party transactions. Managers and supervisors should calibrate the level of scrutiny, detail, supporting evidence and oversight of related party transactions to the risk of improper influence and investor harm in the circumstances. In practice, this means more focus on transactions that are complex, novel or bespoke and present genuine risk to investors.
When assessing the level of risk, managers and supervisors should consider the nature of the benefit, degree of relatedness, level of control or influence, common market engagement, complexity of arrangements, transparency of terms, negotiating power and comparability with the market, including valuation and benchmark availability.
Simple, routine transactions need less detail and evidence and may need only market pricing and fee schedules. Bespoke transactions may need independent valuations and specialist advice. At the high-risk end, such as hard-to-value unlisted assets acquired from a related party, the FMA expects intensive scrutiny, with the matter escalated through governance and early engagement with the supervisor.
The FMA does not regard related party transactions as inherently inappropriate. It expects them to be identified, assessed and managed carefully.
What is a ‘benefit’ for these purposes?
The FMC Act does not define ‘benefit’. The FMA considers that a benefit has a financial or economic character but is wider than direct payments. Where a benefit is not obvious, the FMA suggests asking why the related party wants the transaction and what advantage it gets from it. Benefits can include:
fees, interest or distributions paid from scheme property;
guarantees, funding or liquidity support, or cheaper funding; and
increased funds under management, greater scale, or a better ability to raise capital.
The focus is on the effect of the transaction on the related party. A transaction entered for operational and investor-focused reasons can still give a related party benefit.
Are indirect benefits caught?
A ‘transaction’ can extend beyond the immediate counterparty to downstream entities where this reflects the substance and purpose of the manager’s decision. For example, if a manager invests through an intermediary, such as a wholesale fund, knowing that the investment will ultimately benefit a related party, the rules apply to that downstream benefit. Knowledge includes wilful blindness. The rules cannot be avoided simply by inserting an intermediary in the transaction chain.
If no indirect related party benefit can be identified where proper processes have been followed, the rules will not be engaged.
Investing in a fund is not the same as appointing an investment manager
Contrary to a view held by parts of the market, investing in another fund does not, of itself, make that fund's manager an investment manager. A person will only be an investment manager where the manager has contracted out the investment of some or all of the scheme property to it, for example under an investment management agreement. In those circumstances, that person will be a related party of the scheme.
Whether a third party is an investment manager depends on the facts, including how much investment discretion the manager keeps.
Is an outsourced registry provider a related party?
The FMA has confirmed that an outsourced registry provider is an administration manager and therefore, a related party of the scheme. Where the registry fee is paid out of scheme property (rather than out of the manager’s fee), it is a related party benefit.
Notify and certify before committing
The supervisor notification and related party certificate must be completed before the transaction is entered into. The FMA considers it good practice to share a draft certificate with the supervisor first and expects managers to give supervisors enough time to review it.
What does the FMA say about ‘arm's-length terms’?
The FMA describes arm's-length terms as one of the most common grounds relied on, but also the area with the greatest uncertainty and variability in practice.
A benefit is given on ‘arm's-length terms’ where the terms would be reasonable in the circumstances if the parties were connected or related only by the transaction itself, with each acting independently and in its own best interests, or if the terms are less favourable to the related party.
The evidence must make clear why the terms are reasonable. Saying an agreement is in standard form, without looking at the specific terms or the value of the benefit, is unlikely to be sufficient. The lack of an observable market price does not necessarily rule out the arm's-length exception. What matters is that the evidence is relevant and of sufficient quality to support the certification.
Can a certificate cover multiple transactions?
A single certificate can cover a series of transactions where the key terms, benefits and grounds are known and the same, or very similar, across each transaction. However, a later transaction is not automatically covered simply because it resembles an earlier one.
A binding commitment with a clearly defined scope, such as fixed instalments or capital calls under a committed capital agreement, can be certified as a series.
Similarly, where an investment manager or registry provider is a related party by operation of statutory provisions but is otherwise independent and engaged on ordinary commercial terms, a certificate covering a series of transactions is likely to be appropriate.
Managers should keep series certificates under review and refresh them where there is a material change, for example to fees, mandates or valuations.
If you would like to discuss any of the issues raised in this article, or what the new guidance may mean for your organisation, please contact the authors or your usual Bell Gully adviser.
Disclaimer: This publication is necessarily brief and general in nature. You should seek professional advice before taking any action in relation to the matters dealt with in this publication.