The Commerce Commission’s new guidance on artificial intelligence (AI) is a timely reminder that New Zealand’s competition and consumer protection laws apply regardless of whether conduct results from human decisions or automated systems.
Overview
The Commerce Commission has released new guidance on how New Zealand's competition and consumer protection laws apply to businesses using AI. The guidance includes fact sheets on the Fair Trading Act and Commerce Act implications of using AI, together with more detailed guidance on algorithmic collusion.
For New Zealand businesses, the guidance reiterates the importance of having robust oversight in place to ensure that AI is being used appropriately. While AI systems are growing increasingly complex, businesses should have a reasonable working understanding of how their chosen tools operate including (where possible) what data they rely on and how AI-generated recommendations influence commercial decision-making.
The Commission is also encouraging boards to treat AI as a governance issue, and to maintain visibility of how AI is used across the companies they oversee. Businesses that understand and manage the legal and commercial risks associated with AI will be better placed to realise its benefits while meeting evolving regulatory expectations.
Fair Trading Act when using AI
Digital technologies and AI are changing how New Zealand businesses engage with consumers. As noted in Bell Gully’s previous publications, AI and Consumer Law – key takeaways from Australian review and NZ’s AI strategy: “light touch” regulation and opportunities for businesses, governments overseas are considering whether new regulatory frameworks are needed to address the use of AI. In New Zealand, the Government has so far preferred a “light-touch” approach that relies on existing laws, making the Commission’s guidance on how current consumer protection laws apply particularly important.
The Commission’s guidance reiterates that businesses remain responsible for complying with the Fair Trading Act even when using AI. The Commission highlights several key risk areas for New Zealand businesses, including:
Misleading and deceptive conduct: The same conduct standards apply to AI-generated images or text and to AI chatbots used to provide information to consumers. If relying on disclaimers, it will therefore be important to ensure that any limitations are clearly explained.
Personalised pricing and offers: AI-driven marketing, including personalised pricing, must be clear, accurate and not misleading. Businesses using these tools should be able to explain how prices or offers are set and should avoid telling consumers that all prices are standardised if that is not the case.
Manipulative marketing: Businesses should be careful not to cross the line from persuasive to misleading or deceptive when designing websites or apps that use behavioural biases (or “dark patterns”) to tailor content or influence consumer behaviour. Design features such as false scarcity or urgency cues are likely to attract particular scrutiny.
AI washing: Businesses should accurately present to consumers the abilities and limitations of the AI technology used. Claims about what a product’s AI can do should be capable of substantiation at the time they are made.
The Commission’s consumer law guidance is a helpful reminder that using AI does not shift responsibility away from the business. A business remains answerable for what chatbots and similar tools tell customers. AI can heighten those risks given that systemic errors in consumer-facing AI could result in a widespread breach affecting many customers.
AI also creates a challenge because many organisations may not have a complete picture of where AI is in use, particularly where it is embedded in third-party marketing, pricing or customer service platforms. Businesses should take careful steps to map their customer-facing uses of AI and assign clear responsibility for each. Chatbots should be tested against the questions customers are likely to ask in practice (on refunds, guarantees and product capabilities, for example) and all AI tools should be reviewed periodically for outcomes that could mislead.
AI and the Commerce Act
The Commission's guidance reiterates that businesses are responsible for ensuring their use of AI complies with the Commerce Act. The same legal principles apply whether decisions are made by people, algorithms or AI systems.
For businesses with “substantial market power”, there is a particular risk that AI could be used to exclude rivals – particularly where a business has access to essential data or inputs. The Commission’s guidance highlights examples of conduct that might give rise to competition concerns, including:
digital platforms favouring their own products in search rankings or recommendations;
bundling AI products with essential digital infrastructure such as cloud services; and
using AI-driven analytics to target pricing to exclude rivals.
The guidance also makes clear that the prohibition on mergers and acquisitions that substantially lessen competition extends to acquisitions of critical technologies, data assets and key AI capabilities. This includes so-called "killer acquisitions", where a business acquires an innovative start-up to eliminate future competition.
Algorithmic collusion and AI
While AI tools can improve efficiency, they also create competition law risks, including algorithmic collusion and AI-enabled cartel conduct. Bell Gully examined these risks in detail in its Big Picture Algorithmic collusion and AI cartels: risks under New Zealand Commerce Act publication released earlier this year.
The Commission’s guidance reiterates many of the same points and identifies several ways in which algorithmic collusion may arise, including:
Implementing a cartel using algorithms: Where competitors agree to coordinate prices and then use automated pricing software to implement or monitor that agreement, the fact that pricing is automated does not prevent a breach.
Shared algorithms and platforms: Competitors relying on the same pricing platform or software provider may be at risk where the platform facilitates the exchange of commercially sensitive information or generates recommendations using competitors' confidential data.
Sharing sensitive information: Concerns may arise where pricing algorithms are trained, calibrated or operated using competitors' current or future competitively sensitive information.
Autonomous pricing systems: Advanced AI-driven systems may, under certain conditions, learn to interact and produce coordinated outcomes, potentially without the business's knowledge.
Businesses should take practical steps to identify and manage these competition law risks, including by:
ensuring that pricing and other competitive decisions remain independent of competitors, and that internal or third party systems are not trained on or fed competitors' sensitive information;
maintaining meaningful human oversight, so that staff understand how systems operate and can challenge or override their recommendations and
conducting regular competition compliance audits.
As our Big Picture report noted, AI pricing tools can create competition law risks that are harder to control and less visible than before, and regulators in the US, UK, European Union, Mexico and Brazil are already taking action. With the Commission now setting out its expectations, New Zealand businesses should expect increasing scrutiny in this area.
Bell Gully advises on competition and consumer law compliance, AI governance, regulatory investigations and AI risk management. If you have any questions about the matters raised in this report, please get in touch with the contacts listed or your usual Bell Gully adviser.
Disclaimer: This publication is necessarily brief and general in nature. You should seek professional advice before taking any action in relation to the matters dealt with in this publication.



