In an earlier article, we considered the key questions and considerations arising from the Government’s proposal announced at Budget 2026 to extend the revenue account method (RAM) to calculate foreign investment fund (FIF) income to all New Zealand tax residents and certain eligible trustees from 1 April 2026.
This earlier article was published before the introduction of the Taxation (Annual Rates for 2026-27, FBT Simplification, Foreign Investment Funds, and Remedial Measures) Bill (the Bill), which proposes an extension to the RAM. While the Bill resolves some of the questions we previously raised, it also raises several new questions.
What is the RAM eligibility for trusts?
The Bill proposes to align trust eligibility for the RAM to those trusts that are also eligible to apply the comparative value (CV) method, eliminating the current requirement that the trust must have a principal settlor who is an individual that can apply the RAM themselves. Alignment is a welcome development.
However, eligibility for the extended RAM requires that the trust has a principal settlor who is an individual that is an extended RAM taxpayer. The principal settlor requirement significantly narrows trust eligibility for the extended RAM. Trusts settled by US-resident parents for the benefit of a New Zealand resident, US-citizen child that subsequently enter the New Zealand tax base, for example, by making a complying trust election, are not eligible for the extended RAM. This is despite the trust’s income ultimately being attributable to an extended RAM taxpayer.
What is the expected transition into the RAM?
Currently, taxpayers must decide whether to apply the RAM for a given FIF in the year in which it first qualifies for the RAM.
The Bill proposes greater flexibility. It is proposed that taxpayers can elect to apply the RAM for the first time at any point in time. Taxpayers will have additional time to evaluate whether to apply the RAM to their eligible FIF interests rather than being required to make a permanent decision within the income year in which the eligible FIF interest first qualifies.
As an integrity measure, the Bill proposes that once taxpayers elect to apply the RAM, a five-year consistency rule applies. This requires that the taxpayer use the RAM for five consecutive income years before opting out of the RAM and that the taxpayer must not have used the RAM for five consecutive income years before opting back into the RAM. This restriction on switching methods can be contrasted with the ability of New Zealand tax resident natural persons and certain eligible trustees to switch between the fair dividend rate (FDR) method and the CV method on an annual basis to calculate their FIF income. Taxpayers will need to factor in the five-year consistency rule when choosing between methods.
FIFs held through controlled foreign companies (CFC)
Currently, a taxpayer is limited to the FDR method for FIFs held through CFCs. The Bill proposes to mitigate this limitation by allowing such taxpayers to use the FIF calculation methods available to the taxpayer personally e.g the CV method and the RAM or otherwise apply the FDR method. If the taxpayer chooses to calculate FIF income using the FIF calculation methods available to them, that same method must be applied to FIFs held directly and through a CFC.
However, the Bill acknowledges that the FIF interest continues to be held by the CFC with the income interest attributed to the taxpayer. Therefore, the issues identified in our earlier article concerning the clawback of concessions remain. For example, if a taxpayer elects to apply the RAM to FIFs held through a CFC and there is a disposal of the FIF, the taxpayer benefits from a 30% discount on disposal gains under the RAM. However, if the disposal proceeds are actually distributed by the CFC to the taxpayer as a dividend, the distribution is fully taxable.
The taxpayer will get a credit for tax paid under the RAM, but that credit will be reduced because of the 30% discount inherent in the RAM. This creates inequities between FIFs held directly by taxpayers and those that are held through a CFC. Treating the CFC as transparent for the purpose of distributing proceeds from a FIF would eliminate such issues.
Allowing taxpayers to apply the FIF calculation methods available to the taxpayer personally provides flexibility to use different methods for FIF interests depending on whether those interests are held directly or through a CFC. Generally, a FIF calculation method must be applied across the taxpayer’s entire portfolio. This remains the case where a taxpayer elects to calculate FIF income for interests held through a CFCs using a method available to them personally, rather than the FDR method.
However, under the proposal in the Bill, the taxpayer could apply the FDR method to FIFs held through a CFC, while applying another calculation method, such as the CV method or the RAM, to FIF interests held directly. This could incentivise taxpayers to hold FIF interests suited to the FDR method through a CFC, while holding more speculative FIF interests, such as interests in start-up companies directly and applying the RAM.
How does the all of portfolio basis impact FIFs that are hybrid entities?
Subject to the optional rule for FIFs held through CFCs outlined above, the RAM must be applied on an all of portfolio basis for eligible FIF interests. Taxpayers who apply the RAM are subject to tax on realised gains from eligible FIF interests (subject to a 30% discount) with dividends fully taxed. The RAM may appear to be an improvement over the deemed income derived under other FIF calculation methods, however taxpayers that hold interests in FIFs that are hybrid entities such as US limited liability companies may potentially be subject to high effective marginal tax rates on dividends.
These high effective marginal tax rates are a product of the potential inability to obtain foreign tax credits or a reduction in the quantum of the dividend to account for the tax paid in the foreign jurisdiction. Taxpayers who hold FIF interests in hybrid entities should therefore carefully consider whether electing to apply the RAM to all of their eligible FIF interests provides a better outcome than applying one of the other FIF calculation methods.
What potential issues exist with the exit tax?
The RAM currently includes an exit tax, which gives rise to a deemed disposal of all RAM interests at market value immediately before a taxpayer becomes non-resident for New Zealand income tax purposes. The tax liability arising on the deemed disposal only becomes payable if the taxpayer actually disposes of the RAM interests within three years of becoming non-resident for New Zealand income tax purposes. If the taxpayer holds onto the RAM interests for more than three years after ceasing to be a New Zealand tax resident, no New Zealand tax is payable on the deemed disposal.
The New Zealand tax liability on the deemed disposal does not crystallise if the taxpayer’s exit from their RAM interests is undertaken through the derivation of a dividend. An example of this is where the taxpayer holds a RAM interest in a top-tier foreign entity, and an exit takes the form of a sale of a lower-tier entity or business.
The disposal proceeds are distributed by the top-tier foreign entity to the taxpayer as a dividend, rather than as proceeds of the disposal of the RAM interest itself. This may give rise to inequities between taxpayers depending on the precise form of the exit from the investment. Taxpayers may have little control over how the exit is structured, but its structure could have material tax implications in New Zealand when assessing the exit tax position.
The Bill does not consider such issues. It also proposes that a deemed disposal be triggered where a New Zealand tax resident starts being treated as non-resident under an applicable double tax agreement.
Next steps
We expect the Finance and Expenditure Committee to consider the key questions and issues outlined above before the Bill is enacted, which is expected to take place before 31 March 2027.
If you have any questions about how the proposal to extend the RAM to all taxpayers will impact you, please get in touch with your usual Bell Gully adviser.
Disclaimer: This publication is necessarily brief and general in nature. You should seek professional advice before taking any action in relation to the matters dealt with in this publication.